Walk Around the Rock:

One of Orvieto’s most wonderful amenities is the Anello della Rupe – loosely translated, The Ring Around the Cliff – a footpath that encircles the city. Enter the Anello at any one of its five entrances, and you undergo an instant transformation from Urban Dweller to Woods Hiker.

Directly across a small piazza (now a parking lot) from where I live is Porta Vivaria. Of the old gate only the vertical posts and few stones of the arch remain. Originally, a steep road went from piazza to gate, and past it there were broad steps down to the valley floor. Small livestock were brought through the gate on their way to market in nearby Piazza del Popolo, thus the name “vivaria”. Popolo still hosts the mercato ai fuori every Thursday and Saturday, as it has for centuries (though probably not on the exact same schedule) but no chickens and goats, in case you’re wondering.  Now it’s all clothing and cheese, produce and plants.

The path west from Porta Vivaria overlooks relatively recent excavations of one of the many Etruscan necropoli scattered throughout the area.  The necropolis we’re passing now resembles a village of little cubes with roofs of sod, neat alleys, and sturdy stonework. I tried once to visit the site, but the gate was closed, or it seemed closed and I fell for the ruse. This day, there were visitors wandering around. I’d never seen that before, but it sent a clear signal that the park was open, so I went down to see if I could get in.  Everything was unlocked, I paid my €3, and stepped back in time.

About half the tombs in this necropolis have been excavated, many of them “restored,” that is, missing pieces filled in with new material to stabilize the structures. You can walk around, go inside, touch, sit, breathe, and feel the centuries. It’s really great. The necropolis was build between 2,500 and 2,300 years ago, more or less. The display in the information center suggests that the tombs here were of middle class and upper middle class families rather than for aristocrats; that Velzna (the Etruscan Orvieto) was a relatively egalitarian society with a powerful middle class.

Then in between 300 and 270 BCE something happened. Here’re a couple of excerpts from a Roman source.

“These people were the most ancient of the Etruscans; they had acquired power and had erected an extremely strong citadel, and they had a well-governed state.  Hence, on a certain occasion, when they were involved in war with the Romans, they resisted for a very long time.  Upon being subdued, however, they drifted into indolent ease, left the management of the city to their servants, and used those servants also, as a rule, to carry on their campaigns.  Finally they encouraged them to such an extent that the servants gained both power and spirit, and felt that they had a right to freedom; and, indeed, in the course of time they actually obtained this through their own efforts.

Hence the old-time citizens, not being able to endure them, and yet possessing no power of their own to punish them, despatched envoys by stealth to Rome.”

Rome, eager to please the estranged upper classes, engaged in “corrective intervention.”

This fascinates me. There is an historical hypothesis floating around that Rome was founded by the Etruscans. Without going into this too deeply, there is sense to it. Before the republic, Rome was governed by Tarquinian (Etruscan) kings or dictators. There are Roman histories to justify this oddness, but why would a bunch of Latin miscreants (for Romulus is said to have invited felons and exiles into his city to populate it) eager for freedom invite Etruscans to exercise absolute rule? Well, maybe they needed a kind of warden, but still.

The hypothesis goes on. During republican expansion, the powers-that-be began rewriting history to reflect a more patriotic Roman origin of the city, so Romulus and Remus and the She-Wolf were invented, and the Etruscan influence on culture, religion, and political structure was downplayed. After all, Rome was out to conquer Etruria, and you don’t do that kind of thing to your grandparents if you want to sleep at night. The solution? Change your grandparents. Rome’s was also a profoundly hierarchical society. It was only over time that reforms were made in governance that allowed the common citizen some say in policy and taxation, and slavery was a economic mainstay not to be tampered with.

So, what was going on with Velzna’s middle class that the Romans found so threatening? Were they experimenting with an egalitarian society at a time when the Roman Senate was feeling pressure from below? If Rome was primally Etruscan and the influence was still strong (and Velzna was now under Roman dominion), was this movement in Velzna a direct threat to the Roman power structure? I find the possibilities fascinating.

The archeology museum in town displays frescos that were lifted from one of the larger tombs in another necropolis southeast of the city. Those in the left chamber are of a kitchen staff cheerfully preparing a meal, while the frescoed right chamber shows the meal (possibly the funerary feast for the deceased) being served in a commodious dining room. With a few deft strokes, the artists captured personalities, body types, motion, relationship, and intention. There’s no attempt at realistic anatomical detail, but the figures leap across time; are startlingly familiar.

The paintings are familiar because of their sensitivity to the human form. They are also familiar because the Etruscans are still here, in Orvieto. There are a few people around town whose figures and faces could have been copied from surviving Etruscan art, if life really did imitate art (and who knows, maybe it does?) and many more, while less representative of the Etruscan ideal, still have the features.

Next, we come to Porta Maggiore, the Etruscan city’s only gate. The street that descends to the gate is called Via della Cava. It, and the gate, were cut into the rock by the Etruscans, and the gate’s supporting structure, the pavement, and perhaps a couple of temples in the area were then built from the stone quarried during the cut. When you walk the walls, you pass over the gate partly on original rock. The medieval (and no doubt the Etruscan) town grew up around Porta Maggiore. From there, the street climbs steeply to what is alternately called Piazza Sant’Andrea or Piazza della Reppublica (and casually, Piazza del Comune). Excavations have lead archeologists to conclude that the piazza has been in use as a market center since Etruscan times. The piazza’s eponymous church, Sant’Andrea, is placed on the foundations of both a Romanesque church and an Etruscan temple.

ExCampo2

We continue on the Anello a short distance from Porta Maggiore, and arrive at ex-Campo della Fiera and Foro Boario. The Campo was further out for the Etruscans, both before and during Roman occupation. That site, about a kilometer away from the cliff, is being excavated and foundations of temples and official buildings have been uncovered. They suggest that Velzna was an important spiritual and administrative center, and that the Campo was used both for large regional markets and religious purposes. During the late medieval period, the market activities were moved closer to town. Foro Boario is the name for the cattle market that was also held here. These days, the area is occupied by a parking structure. Barely visible from the valley, it is an elegant piazza from the cliff.

Just past the Foro are the remains of the medieval aqueduct. A hugely ambitious project for its day, it proved to be difficult to maintain. Its history is one of boom and bust, emperor and pope, and ongoing rivalries between powerful families. It reminds me of how any collective effort requires rock solid political stability in order to sustain funding and organization. It’s easy to forget what remarkable times we live in, and how quickly they can dissolve.

Then for awhile, our walk is simply gorgeous. First we come to a row of houses along a bit of street called via (or strada) del Salto di (or del) Livio. The five buildings that look out over green gardens are, at most, a ten minute walk to your favorite coffee bar; shorter if you take the elevator that serves the garage. I’d love to live there.

The name of the street has a tragic, lovelorn history behind it. During the time of the Medici, Orvieto was riven by interfamilial strife. One of the warring families was the Sarancinelli who dominated the quarter now called Serancia, though the family probably took its name from the quarter rather than the other way around. Serancia sits on the cliffs above the street we’re passing now on the Anello.

One of the Sarancinelli was a young man named Livio who tried to set himself apart from the factionalism. By chance, he met a young woman visiting from Rome named Livia (cute, heh?) and they immediately fell in love. This was all very good and fine, but there had been a prophecy that predicted the extinction of the family should one of its members marry a Roman. So cousins of Livio (only thinking of the good of the family, of course) poisoned Livia, and she died three days later in the arms of her beloved. Livio fled to Rome, raised a militia, and returned for his revenge. When his attempts to kill the murders failed, he threw himself off the nearest cliff, and the area into which his body fell is called Salto di Livio; basically, Livio’s Leap.

I’d still love to live there.

Then for another a kilometer or so we pass fascinating cliffs to the left, and to the right, rolling countryside, groves, and farms. The cliffs are fascinating because as they have fallen away over the centuries, caverns, caves, cisterns, rooms, and dovecotes have been revealed. Some of them have been filled in with masonry to prevent further erosion, others are left open, yet others have doors and window frames installed and apparently continued to be put to good use until quite recently.

The butte that Orvieto rests on is riddled with man-made tunnels, rooms, and cavities. The first were cisterns and storm drains carved out by the Etruscans. The Romans expanded these, the Orvietani who followed turned them into storage rooms, cellars, and trash dumps. The resulting labyrinth is comprised of over 1,200 chambers, passages, and wells. Many of Orvieto’s houses include a system of underground excavations that are still used to store wine, oil, and last year’s fashions. My realtor is always quite excited when a property includes caverne as we turn on our cellphone flashlights and eagerly descend.

I discovered early in my stay that going back into town via the next entrance constitutes a vigorous workout. One lengthy climb takes you up to three switchbacks followed by a hundred-fifty steps to street level. After my first ascent – which was, shall we say, not exactly in the manner of a mountain goat – I resolved (panting and sweating) to make the climb two or three times a week. I’ve been doing at least that, and my climbing abilities have improved, though not yet of goat caliber. At the top you’re rewarded, in spring and summer at any rate, with a rose garden. This entrance is named Palazzo Crispo-Marsciano. I like repeating the name. It’s fun. Palazzo Crispo-Marsciano. Palazzo Crispo-Marsciano.

“Crispo” was Tiberio Crispo, father of Pope Paul III. “Marsciano” was Ludovico dei Conti di Marsciano, a busy fellow who fought Turks for the Venetians and lead the Papal armies in Hungary. Now the palazzo is an office of the Tax Police. Really.

Next stop on the Anello, after a few more steep hills and valleys, is the double gate that abuts Fortezza Albornoz. In Etruscan times it was the site of a temple (what wasn’t?) that has been since named Augurale. Its first incarnation as a fort was a project of Cardinal Albornoz, a general and military advisor to Pope Innocent VI (a misnomer if ever there was one,) with a start date of 1364. It was destroyed in 1390, rebuilt in 1395, reinforced in 1413, and mostly destroyed except for the perimeter walls sometime later. Around 1527, Clement VII, concerned that if there were a siege he and his townsmen might run out of water, and having had a bad time of it when the French sacked Rome, began construction on Pozzo di San Patrizio. A remarkable bit of engineering, the well achieves a depth of 53 meters and is served by a double helix so that mules going down for water can keep right on going up again without meeting any of their descending brethren.

The fact that the gate next to the fort has several names, and is still known by all of them – each with authoritative historical roots – says something about Orvieto’s ability to tolerate contradiction, but I’m not exactly sure what. That I’m at all worried about the multiple names probably says something about me, too, and of that I can probably guess. The gate is variously called Porta Rocca, Porta Soliana, and Porta Postierla.  I’ve even heard it casually referred to as Porta Albornoz and La Porta della Fortezza. The Outsider: I mean, really, people, we’ve had like a thousand years to work this through, can we arrive at a consensus, please? Orvieto: We need to? Why?

To the left, the Anello takes us over the funicular track, on through its woodiest section, and, after another couple of kilometers, back to Porta Vivaria.

The funicular was built in 1888 to connect the new railway line with the upper town. It was originally a hydro-balance system. Water was pumped into the upper car as it took on passengers, and out of the lower at the same time. Then a brake was released, and the two cars, connected to the same cable loop, switched places. The line was abandoned in 1970 (bad years for urban life everywhere,) electrified in 1990 and re-opened shortly thereafter. It runs every 10 minutes from 7:10 am to about 8:30 pm, thereby proving to be teasingly useless to morning commuters who have to catch the train to Rome that leaves at 6:57. Some things are universal.

Were we to continue to the right instead, we arrive in Scalo, the lower city, via a paved footpath (paved a long time ago, so don’t picture asphalt.) Orvieto Scalo gets its name from the scales that used to weigh goods coming into and going out of town so they could be taxed. This was during the days of the Papal States. There are lots of interesting surviving oddities from those times in habit, law, custom, and cuisine. I’ll do a post one of these days.

What I find particularly wonderful about the Anello is that you can decide to hike it almost on a whim. Enjoy a hearty lunch, stroll over to a bar, throw down a caffe macchiato, and, wow! I feel like a walk. Let’s do the Anello! Minutes later you’ve left behind the urban crush, noise, and oppressive bustle of Orvieto (winky, smiley face,) and are surrounded by nature.

It was perhaps this sort of thing that inspired New York’s city planners to conclude that a central park would be a good idea.  It is an excellent idea.

Confessions of a Gelatophiliac:

During my first stay in Orvieto fifteen years ago, I discovered Gelateria Pasqualetti. The ice cream they served was comparable to anything you would find at Vivoli di Firenze. Everyone agreed. Orvieto was blest.

I’m there years later and ask for the restroom. I’m directed up some stairs that take me through a kind of mezzanine overlooking the kitchen. The view is from a Flemish painting, piled with crates of peaches, lemons, berries, oranges, chocolate, nuts. It’s a rainbow of flavor that justifies the magnificent gelato vended below. The perfect balance of sweet and tart, the luscious textures, the modest portions, it all makes sense looking at that kitchen. Classic Italian quality in a classic Italian product served in the classic Italian manner.

I loved Pasqualetti. I bragged about it to anyone who would at least make an effort to conceal the rolling of their eyes out of respect (or pity) for my obsession.

In March 2014, I lead a group of students from Marywood University on a week’s study tour to Orvieto. I told them all about Pasqualetti. They were stoked to try it. I arrive a few days ahead of time to set up, and make my primal pilgrimage the next afternoon. A sign taped to the door says, “Closed for the winter.” I gripe to anyone I can rely on to conceal their boredom out of pity (or fatigue) for my emotional devastation.

The next day, I pass a satellite store Pasqualetti had opened on Via del Duomo. I’m thrilled and immediately order my customary first combination; nocciola, caffè, cioccolato, in coppetta piccola. As the gelato is being scraped into the larger-that-I-remember cup, I imagine my students’ faces lighting up at their first taste of the real thing.

One of the things I cherish about the traditional gelateria – I don’t know why – is the small cup portion. It’s actually small. You order a small anything in most fast food shops in the States and are given what was called extra-super-large a mere twenty years ago. When I order small, I want to receive small. It’s a matter of principle.

Larger than I remember. Pasqualetti’s “small” is at least 50% bigger than what used to be their “medium” and it costs three euro. The cup is also overfilled. I’m a little disturbed, but what’s a cup, anyhow? It’s what’s in the cup that counts. I taste my first spoonful.

The gelato is sweet. Very sweet. So sweet, I can’t taste anything but sugar. Larger cup, fancy graphics, a branch store with more visibility, twice the sugar. Something’s afoot, it’s not pretty, and I don’t really want to know the truth. I feel betrayed and more than I realize, and am deeply reluctant to face the fact.

My students arrive, they sample the gelato at Pasqualetti and at the “new” place on Corso Cavour, L’Officina del Gelato, and they naturally compare. They ask which of the stores I was going on about back home, and roll their eyes when I tell them. Out of respect for their brutal honesty (and inexperience), I pretend to look away.

A few days later, I mention my suspicions to a friend. He confirms my fears.  The Pasqualetti family no longer owns the business. The new owners cater to American tourists and imported American tastes, and that demands large portions and lots of sugar. Then he goes through the list of profit-boosting adjustments made, all of them, in his opinion, at the sacrifice of the product. By the time he’s through with his report, I’m a psychological wreck.

Last May, I still couldn’t come to grips. I’d tasted the product at L’Officina and declared it inferior to what Pasqualetti used to serve. I was spiteful, or lovesick, or both. Attached. Blinded by the past.

Barely a day passed between May and October when I didn’t at some point contemplate my resistance. Pasqualetti had sold out. L’Officina opened shortly after. Maybe there’s a connection. Maybe I ought to give the young rebel a fair trial.

When I arrive back in October my first gelato is at L’Officina. It’s good. In fact, it’s very, very… very good. Rich, deep flavors, not over sweet, it’s served in an actual coppetta piccola, and costs two euro. The gelatophiliac heaves a sigh of relief. I have since returned at least four times a week.

Around four o’clock is usually when, if I’m going to have a pick-me-up, I head for l’Officina. Today at four I walk to Corso Cavour and turn right. A few more paces puts the storefront in sight. Hmmm, the awning is up. The awning is never up during business hours. My heart beats a little faster. Ahead of me, a man stands at the door. He stares at a piece of paper taped to the glass, turns away in confusion, looks back. I reach the door and see it. “Closed through March 4.” We turn to each other and groan.

“It’s very good gelato,” says the man to no one in particular (his son is still across the street.) “There’s no better. I don’t know. This is bad.”

I agree.

“Then let’s go and get some cake, instead,” says the son, joining him.

I roll my eyes, but out of respect for his youthful stupidity, I’m discrete about it. They go off for cake.

I stand facing the door, staring at that sign. Cake? How is cake a substitute for gelato? That’s absurd. And once used to the best, in a small cup, how could I ever go back to… the other place? I can’t. I’ll just have to give it up until March. No other choice. Maybe give up sugar entirely. I’ve done it before. It just seems so anti-Italian. But then, that’s my view from decades ago, Italy has changed, it’s time for me to change with it.

I walk in circles, mumbling to myself. Passersby arch away. I twitch a few times, and sigh again. Then I go and get some cake.

Dental Health:

Sometime in November, a dental implant that has fallen out several times in the past two years, did it again. My dentist in Scranton had warned me it might. Privately, this was the thing I most hoped would not happen. No dental issues while in Italy, I just didn’t think I could navigate that.

By chance, a friend of mine had told me of a dentist she really liked about a week before the implant fell out. So, I texted her. “Who is this guy and how do I find him?” She gave his office a call, and was told I should come on over that afternoon. No appointment necessary.

So, implant in a baggie, I go.

A nice young woman takes my information. There’s no front desk, she squats by a coffee table while she fills out a form. It’s basic stuff like name and address and numbers of various kinds. She asks if I can wait for about a half hour, I say, sure, and she goes off.

I rifle through the reading material. It’s all interesting. I pick a copy of Sette, a weekly news magazine. It’s a good read, articles about a variety of subjects, most of it within my ability to understand.

Awhile later a young man comes out and stands in front of the coffee table. In Italian, “So, what’s up?” I don’t know who he is, but he seems to have the right to ask, so I show him the implant in a baggie and introduce myself. “Giuseppe,” he answers, and shakes my hand. “Come on back.” I follow him into a room that is combination office and examination area, all very nicely furnished and with some impressive looking dental equipment. “Have a seat.”

This little guy with the beautiful eyes and pleasant face, in a surgeon’s cap that lets a few black curls out just over his ears, wearing a lumpy lab coat over super casual clothes that are too large for him and the blue and silver sneakers, is Dottore Giuseppe. He looks about 23. From the dates on the certificates in the waiting room I find he’s forty.  I would never have guessed. His hands are remarkably graceful. Both in appearance and manner he reminds me of a physical comedian from the silent film era. He asks me several questions about health then invites me into the examination chair. A few minutes of poking around, he says we need x-rays.

I hate dental x-rays. Biting that film hurts, no matter what kind of armature they come up with to try to make it better. So, I am not happy at this moment. We go into the other room, equipped for dental work only (no office furniture) and he sits me down at a machine, tells me to hold still, and turns it on. In about fifteen seconds it takes a full scan of my teeth and sends it to his laptop. X-rays done, let’s take a look.

The implant was anchored on roots that are now breaking, so they will have to come out. “It won’t be bad, we use drugs here to make you happy. In fact, they’re so much fun, you might want to come back even without any dental work.” I’m back a couple of weeks later, a little bit dreading it in spite of Giuseppe’s upbeat promotional. I’d never had roots pulled before, but it didn’t sound like something I would enjoy.

Fontana Olmo
turn here to find Giuseppe’s studio

He’s right about the drugs, though. I think it might be what we used to call laughing gas. They strap a very modern contraption to my nose, not at all awkward or uncomfortable, and we wait. After a couple of minutes Giuseppe asks “How do you feel?” “Normal,” I reply. “Okay, we’ll wait some more,” and he stands in mock anticipation of a great event. A few minutes later, “Now?” “Drunk.” “We’re ready!” he shouts, but quietly, and his team springs into action. Some novocaine, ten minutes, and several dryly delivered witticisms later, he is stitching it up.

I come back the next week to have the stitches out, and mention that I am due for a cleaning. He looks around at his staff, says “Anyone want to do that now?” “Now? That’s not necessary.” “Why not? You’re here.” Someone volunteers, and off we go.

Then about a week ago, the area of the root extraction began to hurt a little. Last night the part of my tongue next to it started to hurt, too. It quickly became  painful to chew, and I wondered if I shouldn’t have it checked out; maybe there was an infection developing.

I stop in today about 1:30 to ask for an appointment. I describe the problem to the woman I meet on the way in, who just happens to be passing between rooms, and she tells me to wait. Giuseppe comes out and I repeat my story. He asks an assistant if he has time to check on it right away. He does. Five minutes later Giuseppe is explaining that it’s a bone spur that might work itself loose in two or three weeks, or he could pull it out instead, my choice. “Take it out.” I’m given an appointment for two hours later.

This time, while waiting I read a travel magazine. The cover story is “48 Hours in New York,” so I peruse that ridiculous notion, first. The next article is by a woman who lived with her husband and son in Topanga Canyon, Big Sur, and Trinity County in the seventies, and who has returned on a sentimental journey. I’m totally engrossed. Suddenly Giuseppe is in front of me. “I called several times. Guess you got lost in the woods. Come on back.” Novocaine (no gas, unfortunately) some poking around, some pulling, a couple of stitches, and we’re done.

After the procedure, I make another appointment to have the stitches out, the woman wishes me good day, and leaves the room. I stand there for a few bewildered moments, then follow her. “What do I owe?” She gives the Italian equivalent of pfft and says “Niente.” I can’t believe it, so I sort of repeat the question, but less strongly so it won’t seem rude. “Why would we charge you for something like that?”

I say goodbye to Giuseppe. He gives me instructions. I thank him for seeing me so quickly. His eyes grow soft and he says “Of course,” but he’s actually thanking me for thanking him.

I never thought I’d know the day when I kind of want things to go wrong with my teeth.

Medieval Jazz:

I can’t let the weekend pass without writing about Umbria Jazz Winter.

This is the event that gets Orvieto through to spring, economically. I was on my way back from my second concert, when I stopped by the alimentaria my friends Vera and Giovanni own to wish them a happy new year. The crowds were formidable, but not quite up to snuff as far as Vera was concerned. She asked about attendance.  When I told her well-attended but not quite full, she twisted her hands and hoped things would pick up over the weekend.

They did.

The group I heard that night was Light of Love Gospel Singers from Chicago. They’re a powerful

bunch and create gorgeous music. They had a concert-combo-mass planned for New Year’s at the Duomo. My friend Claudia wanted to see that, and I did, too.  We agreed to meet across from the Duomo fifteen minutes before the announced starting time. Yeah, right

At about 4:20, Claudia calls. She’s driven in from Monterubiaglio and the garage at ex-Campo della Fiera is closed, full up. So she drove around to the railway station that has a huge lot behind it, and found a space. But the station for the funicular that brings you up into town, was mobbed; no way she was going to make it up in time.

When I arrived at the Duomo, the entry line stretched around to the north door.  It that doesn’t mean anything to you, just picture really, really long. The line moved rather quickly.  I pictured seats gradually filling up inside, and hoped for the best. A few minutes later I entered the cathedral. Most of Italy of was already there.  Not only were there no seats left, there were barely places left to stand.

I was fortunate and found a spot along the north wall where I could lean. Somewhere way in the distance a mass began. I caught a glimpse of a bishop in full regalia between two columns (just to the left of the ubiquitous shark balloon in the photo.) After awhile there was singing.  It was nice. In the meantime, about 50 people a minute were still arriving while 30 people a minute filtered out. I stayed for an hour before I had to leave for the next concert. It was a odd experience, but I couldn’t help but think that this kind of crowd was what the Duomo was built for.

Last evening’s concert was Jarrod Lawson & the Good People. The fellow who introduced them said they were very young. I’d seen a photo of Jarrod and knew this didn’t mean pre-teen, but wasn’t quite prepared for how young they are. Six musicians in their early twenties, remarkably talented, loads of class, incredible poise. They have another concert this evening that starts just about the time I usually go to sleep, but I’m going. I don’t care if it’s identical.

UPDATE –

Romero Lubambo.  All you need to know. He’s Brazilian, a guitarist, and takes that instrument to places I didn’t know if could go. If you ever have the chance to hear him, do not pass it up.

FURTHER UPDATE —

Funk Off.   A marching jazz band.  Kind of a big band sound, but funky.  They do coordinated movement and marching band figures, all kind of funky.  I don’t suppose they’ll be coming to your neighborhood, soon, but if they do…

La Maglia Bianca (with English subtitles)

It first caught my eye sometime before Christmas. A corner store on Corso Cavour, not far from the L’Officina del Gelato – in fact, almost across the street. It was displayed in the window that faced the cross street, whatever it’s called, on the middle mannequin.

A white sweater. I don’t normally take to sweaters with zippers, but this one got me from the get go. It was bulk knit, with a kind of cable pattern, but not your typical cable. It could zip into a turtleneck (and I love turtlenecks) and the inside of the collar was lined with something that looked like lamb’s wool. I saw it, and I knew I was meant to wear it someday.

But it was just before Christmas, I had overspent my monthly (self-imposed) allowance, and prices would drop after Epiphany. So, I’d wait. Two days later I had second thoughts, and went back to the corner window. The sweater was gone. Oh, well. Not meant to be.

About a week later in a window across the street and a bit towards Piazza della Reppublica, the sweater appeared again. The previous window had displayed it under a jacket, but this time it was alone in all its splendor. One look convinced me that I should buy it, and buy it now. But it was riposa, the afternoon closing. I promised myself to check back later that evening. The evening came, something else caught my attention, and I forgot.

The next morning, I woke up determined to go back as soon as the shops opened. I did. The sweater was no where to be seen. Weird.  I checked the surrounding shops in case I’d been mistaken.  Nothing.  The shop in question was one of those really gorgeous places that always intimidate me. I feel like I’d have to already be wearing their clothes in order to meet the dress code. So, I decided not to go in to inquire, and bid the white sweater goodbye.

A couple of days ago, during riposa, I was on my way up to the “supermarket” at the end of my daily walk, and in a window across the street and a little ways down, was the sweater, displayed as the first time, under a jacket. The tag on it said €36. That’s a good price, I thought. Epiphany has passed, the prices are as low as they’re likely to be, I’m going to buy it. But it was riposa, so I did my grocery shopping and vowed to come back later. The evening came, something else caught my attention, and I forgot.

Yesterday morning, I woke up determined to buy the white sweater at some point. The fact that the sales were on, the crowds were gone, and it was Wednesday (who knows why that counted?) gave me confidence that the sweater was going to be on display for awhile. But I’d take no chances. At the end of my walk today, on my way up to the “supermarket,” I peered into every store along Corso because I wasn’t entirely confident I had remembered the location correctly.

Someone had put dry ice into a storm drain along the way. It oozed onto the street quite eerily. This should have been a warning.

I arrived at the shop across the street and a little ways down from the “supermarket.” The tags there look familiar. I think this is the store. But the sweater is no longer on display. This time, I’m going in. It’s five o’clock, they’re open, nothing is stopping me.

“Buona sera.”

The young lady replies. I describe the sweater and mention that I think I saw it in this display window the day before. Does she remember?

“Oh, we have sweaters here with zippers, and there with zippers.” “No, you see, I don’t absolutely need a sweater, I just liked this sweater,” I explain.

She laughs.

“Have you changed the display recently?”

“No.”

“So this sweater I’m describing doesn’t ring any bells?”

“I’m sorry, no.”

“Oh.  I must have the wrong shop.

I walked all the way back down Corso Cavour to Piazza Cahen. No sweater. I walked all the way up Corso Cavour until I had nowhere to go except over the cliff. No sweater.

I decided I would walk down, ask the young woman again. On the way, close to where I first sighted the sweater (and while I was gazing over the cliff edge contemplating the faltering state of my sanity) two young men had planted themselves and were singing. They had the voices of angels, a perfect blend, and were presenting an impromptu concert of mostly-American acoustic pop. I couldn’t figure out what their native language was. The lyrics seemed to be in English, but I couldn’t say for sure. When I applauded, one of them said “Gracias” instead of “Grazie.” Maybe they were Spanish? I reached into my pocket for some change. All I had was a penny. I couldn’t give them a penny, they deserved at least a euro.

I had forgotten to buy milk when I was at the “supermarket” earlier, so I went back down. I’d buy the milk, get change, and return. The milk was bought, the change was had. While I was there, I looked again at the display window across the street. Of course, nothing had appeared in my absence.  You never know.

I walked back up, and gave the young men two euro. They sang “Hallelujah.”

I returned to the clothing store this morning hoping to find the owner. Surely she would have more knowledge of stock, memory of display. She’s very nice, the owner. I described the white sweater in detail. She showed me sweaters here with zippers and there with zippers. After I had rejected those, I waited for her to go to “the back” to see what she had in stock that fit my description. No. There is no “back,” what you see is what there is.

Now here’s the thing; she had no recollection of the sweater that I saw in her window two days earlier. Not even a glimmer.

Maybe the whole drama was all a cleverly contrived, live episode of Twilight Zone. Or maybe it’s just Italy.

Roman Slaps American:

I’d seen the posters around town – Presepe Vivente a San Giovenale, and my curiosity was poked.

I walk to the piazzetta in front of San Giovenale everyday as a kind of pilgrimage to a spectacular panorama; so varied, harmonious, and breathtakingly beautiful that watching it becomes a form of meditation. I had seen things going on in the garden immediately below, cliff-side of the old church – little huts being constructed, piles of fire wood collected – and wondered what that was about. I never put it together with the Presepe Vivente.

My actor friend Andrea Brugnera (way to the left in the photo) emailed me day before yesterday. He’s been in Perugia rehearsing, wanted to let me know that he was in town for a few days and maybe we’d see each other at the Presepe Vivente. He’d be there as a figurante (a costumed participant). That was the focus I needed. I checked the posters for time and showed up a few minutes late. Hundreds of people were streaming towards the church. I was already excited.

First, a little background. San Giovenale is Orvieto’s oldest church, originally put up in the mid 1,000’s. Like the Duomo and Sant’Andrea, it’s believed to have been built on Roman foundations that, in turn, sit on Etruscan ones. I suspect that well before the Etruscans put up their temples, a previous people worshipped there, too. You can sense thousands of years of holy ground when you go into any of those churches. How they celebrated, or what their concept of the divine was, hardly matters.  Persistence leaves its traces.

The open space to the fore of San Giovenale used to hold community gardens. Orvieto was filled with cultivated land; private gardens associated with a house, great or small, as well as large vineyards and orchards on the outskirts. Most of those larger tracts were located along the cliffs’ edge. The cliffs have never been absolutely stable, and I suspect houses were kept away because losing a patch of vineyard to a slide was less traumatic than losing your guest room — and maybe your guest with it.

After the second world war, the cliffs were reinforced with masonry and concrete, and most of the vineyards, orchards, and public gardens were filled in with houses and apartments. (Not always in that order.)  The private gardens are largely still around, but can only be glimpsed briefly through open gates.  The garden in front of San Giovenale is one of the few open gardens that survived.  It’s now designated as a park.

It was in that park that the Presepe Vivente was held. I brought my American skepticism with me in case I began to feel foolish being there. I imagined something like the living Nativities that I saw as a kid, populated by twitching seven year old Josephs, shepherds in bathrobes, and sleepy Marys.  My skepticism didn’t hold up very well. As soon I was on the descending entrance path, lined with torches and potted flames, enchantment began to take over.

The park had been transformed into an Italian notion of what Bethlehem might have been like had the Nativity taken place in the high middle ages, and all the buildings had been of straw.  But the people made it alive.  There were dozens of Orvietani in costume. They were grilling meat, drizzling toast with (excellent) olive oil, and ladling out mulled spiced and honied wine into little plastic cups. They were carding and spinning wool next to sheep who ostensibly had provided it. They were collecting persimmons and grinding things in mortars using pestles. There were heaps of baskets, and tables laden with wooden dish-ware and terra cotta. Watching over it all were a couple of red-crested Roman soldiers, ready perhaps to quell a riot — or to slap a skeptical American back into reality.

Nobody was pretending anything, they were just hanging out as they were, being themselves in this fancifully created environment, and it worked (acting students, take note.) None of it was convincingly Aramaic or of the time of Augustus, but it was so unselfconsciously festive, how could I be skeptical? Why would I want to be?

Curve around back towards the elevated entrance and you’ll discover beneath it two natural grottos. They served as a manger, the presepe.  

I wasn’t able to see the figuranti there until after the story had been acted out, the crowds were too thick.  But there was a real infant (though clearly, and thankfully, a bit more than a few days old) a lovely couple (Mary on the plump side and quite beautiful) a laggard shepherd or two carrying lambs, and a few angels (way more relaxed than you find in Renaissance art, but why not?) I missed the arrival of the magi, but ladies on the ledge above sang hauntingly, and the flames, the smoke, the visitors, the costumes, and the sheer exuberance of it all, made missing the story of no consequence.  The celebration of the coming of the light was in the simple joy of being there.

Masters of the Ordinary:

Orvieto is filled with artists. There are painters and musicians, potters and leather workers, photographers, performers, and artisans creating things which, as yet, have no name.  There is also the artist whose art is part of her trade.  She may not think of herself as artistic at all, but she knows all about medium, context, and form.

I’ve seen evidence of bad taste.  At the open market in Piazza del Popolo, for example, there are items for sale that take your breath away.  But I don’t encounter the real thing very often. Apartments I’ve been invited into, or have glimpsed from the street, are unusually pleasant in their design and décor. The thirteenth century arch that leads to the dining room with the nineteenth century furniture is balanced by the canny placement of a twenty-first century lamp. That easy spontaneity shows up everywhere once your eye grows used to looking for it.

What really impresses me, though — maybe because it’s all over town, all of the time — is the design of shops and window displays.

 Orvieto’s window and shop art seems to be homegrown, not the product of professionals from Rome.  The variety is too great, the attention to detail, too specific.  That idea was reinforced by the shop owners who smiled at the Outsider pointing a camera at their stores.  They nodded in that way that says “we did that.” There’s a different nod for “I bought that.” I’m pretty sure it was the “we did that” nod, most of the time.

Displays range from the practical setups in the open markets to shop interiors that are sometimes so detailed they become environmental installations.  That approach is so prevalent, that even walking into a pharmacy can feel like a designed immersive experience.

But the shop windows are scenographic gems, and you don’t have to step inside to appreciate them.  They exist all over town, not just in the heavily trafficked thoroughfares. The front window of a shop tucked away in a narrow residential street can be as spectacularly attractive as one on Corso Cavour.

However visible a window is, most change more or less constantly.  Some keep a personal style going while shifting detail to reflect the season, or the owner’s mood, or new products.  Others undergo full transformations on a regular basis. The creativity, time, thought, and care invested in all this is staggering.

Then again, so much energy here is devoted to making everyday life, beautiful.  The displays are a vibrant public expression of that.  They are about more than advertizing product or trade, or boosting sales.  They show pride of place, delight in culture, personality, a shared aesthetic, and a rich sense of humor.  I find myself stopping at some windows like I do frescos in Firenze.

These photos capture a little of that, but don’t really do the subjects justice. The light is odd, I didn’t know how to handle the reflections, and the streets were so full there was no place to stand. They strain in the way that panorama shots often do. It’s hard to capture vibrance with pixels — or at least my pixels seem to be not quite up to the task.

 

 

Oh, well.

Imagine the rest.

Or come see it in person.

Auguri!

The Italian Greeting:

I suspect it’s like this when learning any language on the hoof, but Italian requires a whole lot more than memorizing words and complicated grammar. Meaning is attached to all kinds of non-verbal elements too: tonal structures, gestures, expectations, social status, the color of your sweater, educational achievements, and a host of other barely perceivable signals, none of which are written down so you can study them.

When signals are awkwardly employed by the eager-to-please outsider, they often carry wholly different meanings from what the outsider intended, ones that could put said outsider into some serious trouble. It’s not just what you say that counts, it’s when, how, where, to whom, and within which context.

Here’s a handy example. I was waiting to order cheese. There were two elderly ladies behind me who I could not convince to step in front of me, so when the gentleman with the cheese knife nodded in my direction, I leapt. “Si! Vorrei un peccorino… blah, blah, blah.”

Terrible mistake.

In my country, as I wait in line for service I often rehearse ways of taking as little time as possible to conduct the business at hand. When my turn comes, I leap. It’s meant as a courtesy. The people behind me in line advance more quickly. The person taking care of my business, who is assumed to be wishing she were somewhere else, needs to spend less energy on me. It is a civilized if not exactly pleasant way of doing things. Thus I have been trained, and such is my belief.

There are adjustments to be made in Orvieto.  (What follows is my conjecture based on semi-informed observation.)  Say you’re thinking of buying a jacket at the haberdasher down the street, you may just find it convenient to ask someone behind a counter for their opinion. That’s okay.  Maybe he wants to know about your experience at a certain hotel in Prague. Fill him in, all the details, find it on your phone so he has the web address. If anyone else in line feels the need to be served, they will interrupt and tell you as much. It’s all very sensible. But whatever you do, show good form. To be polite is more than manners, it’s patrimony. To be unnecessarily efficient may come off as maleducato, that is, rude.

Every encounter, commercial or otherwise, begins with buon giorno up until a mysterious point mid-afternoon when everyone somehow knows to change to buona sera, which means good afternoon, good evening, good night, and if it’s still dark (and the parties in question have not yet been asleep) maybe even good morning. If you are not greeted by the cheese man, or by whomever it is you’re doing business with, it does not matter. Greet anyway. A reciprocal greeting will almost certainly follow.

I failed in this, and the nice cheese man never forgave me. I immediately caught what I had omitted, and did everything linguistically possible to make up for it – except of course to apologize. I gave him per favoreperfettoprego and esato as often as I could fit them in, even when they were not really called for. When I left, I wished him buona giornata AND arrivaderci. He replied, buon giorno just to make sure I understood that saying goodbye was of no use when I had not yet said hello.

Underlying the ceremony, there is a serious point to this. The proprietor and the client are equals. There should be nothing in either the trade of goods or of words to suggest otherwise. The money is exchanged for a product, yes, but the more significant exchange is one of comfort, information, inclusion, communication, and approval. The greeting expresses both parties’ readiness to enter into the dance, and to leave the greeting out puts everything out of balance.

Another thing I find interesting is that it has been mostly people under the age of thirty-five or so who have been upset when I forget to greet. I find it hopeful that younger people seem to care so much. The guy at the outdoor market with the creased face and calloused hands nods when I greet him and waits for me to make a choice so he can get on with his day. (I suspect this is especially true when serving outsiders who have no useful information to share, anyway.) But the line between the cares and the care-nots is vague. Greet. It don’t cost nothin’, and the avenues it opens up can be quite pleasant.

Until about a week ago – or in other words, for the first five or six weeks of this stay – going into centro to shop or seek information was always tinged with terror. Invisible rules are in effect, and not only am I ignorant, but I unknowingly break them more or less without pause. Then something changed. My purpose on this journey (or in life, as far as that goes) is not to prove that I know stuff. I’m going to make mistakes. So long as I say buon giorno or buona sera at the top of an interaction, no one really seems to care about the rest. They’re too busy making their own mistakes. This language and this culture are built on such ancient foundations, that nobody can navigate them perfectly.

So, hey! I wanna know what it’s like to live here? I’m living it just like an Italian, only my grammar really, really sucks.  Buona serata!

A Tale of Two Towns:

I grew up in Sunnyvale, California in the 1950’s. When I was born, its population was about 5,000.  By the time I turned ten, that had risen to nearly 50,000. When I left for college, there were more than 120,000. Those surges of population were a kind of invasion, we were colonized by teZarko Corner 2 Croppedchnology.

The Sunnyvale I knew as a child was rural and agricultural. It rests in the heart of the Santa Clara Valley, which enjoyed (and probably, in a highly theoretical sense, still enjoys) some of the best conditions for year-round sustainable horticulture in the world. This was conveniently ignored when Lockheed began hiring in the thousands and real estate values shot up to previously inconceivable levels. The Sunnyvale I left when I was 19 was the aging core of a what had managed to survive the blitz, surrounded by tacked-on “subdivisions”.

My parents continued to live in the house they raised me in through retirement, old age, and decline. They both died in that house.  It was recently taken down, along with the one next to it, so that a not-terribly-unattractive office building could be erected. There are pockets of the town I knew as a kid that still remain, but many of the older homes have either been replaced with more impressive ones, or enlarged to be less incompatible with the rational use of such expensive land.

The downtown I walked to almost every day when I was young was torn down in 1980, replaced by a Town Centre, which in turn was torn down about 25 years later, long after it had proven itself unsustainable.  It is being replaced by an Downtownas-yet-to-be-completed “planned downtown.” The single block from before the devastation of 1980 that was allowed to remain is the only part of the downtown area that continued to flourish.

I can’t go home, almost none of it exists anymore.

But I enjoyed growing up there.

I walked to school from the age of six. I walked to church. I walked to hang out in stores and admire their goods, and no one ever questioned me about it. There were shops run by people who owned, loved, and created them. There where department stores like Penny’s and Hart’s, manned by the same sales staff for years on end who knew my evolving tastes and helped to inform them. When I started high school, the walk was longer but still possible. Part of it took me through a cherry orchard, then Mathilda Avenue was Frazer & Zarkopushed through, and I followed the same path on a sidewalk still surrounded by trees.

My mother died in 2007 and with her passing my Sunnyvale walks ended. That was okay, they had become exercise. There weren’t many places left to walk to, or when you could, the walk had grown so unpleasant by proximity to roaring lines of traffic that it hardly seemed worth the effort. But unless I move, regularly, I want to jump out of my skin, so in my mother’s final years I walked in S and U curves, up and down blocks, identifying changes, recalling friends and family and friends of family and where they used to live and work.

Now, until late spring, I’m living in Orvieto, Italy. It’s a hill town on a volcanic outcropping surrounded on all sides by cliffs that drop away into a green valley.

Medeovale 4My days are a luxury. I can write without distraction, settled into an pleasant rhythm made possible by retirement income. I don’t need a car because I never have to leave town. Should that change, I can catch a train. I live on a fringe, only gently touched by the daily struggles that people here, as anywhere, are faced with. The thrum of modern life attracts with a similar pull as in other less insular towns, but I can ignore it.

I walk often. Every walk has a destination, or can be made to have one. I’m getting to know the people who own the shops and restaurants and coffee bars, and whose personalities they reflect. Everywhere, I see people I’ve met; on the street, at the bakery, the wine shop, the chocolate shop, in the piazzas. A little longer walk will take me into the countryside where there are orchards and gardens that help to feed the town. There is an ease to life here that has been so familiar, but I’ve not been able to identify why.

Today, I suddenly saw the connection between Orvieto and the Sunnyvale of my childhood.  It isn’t so strange that it took me two months to find it, because visually the two places could not be more different. Sunnyvale was founded in what may have been, conservatively speaking, Orvieto’s twenty-fourth century. Its houses have always been separated by yards with lawns and fences and trees. In Orvieto, all that gardening is modestly concealed behind stone walls.

Sunnyvale grew out of a tradition rooted in places like Orvieto.  In Sunnyvale, the tradition was abandoned in the rush towards growth – perhaps hardly even noticed – whereas Orvieto seems acutely aware of how fragile its genre of community is within the larger scope of modern city life.  While many people here express some pride in the vast Coop Supermercato in the lower part of the city called Orvieto Scalo, there’s also (thankfully) an awareness that such enterprise can suck the life out of an old-style town, dry it up before anyone knows what happened.

I hope that awareness is more than a product of my eager imagination, because what Orvieto, and places like it, have managed to sustain encourages human dignity in ways that Sunnyvale, impressive as its growth and expansiveness have been, neglects. The ready ease that still exists in these towns is difficult to find, let alone maintain, in the Sunnyvales of the world.

Ever since my first experience of the Italian city forty years ago, I’ve been trying to incorporate the ease that draws me here into my life in the States – or at least simulate it – with mixed results. I’m not sure it can be done at all, but it’s worth a try. Much to their credit, a few of the communities surrounding Sunnyvale have preserved their Pecorellidowntowns.  That helps.  But ease cowers from traffic and institutionalized commercialism, and urban spread depends on those.  In such environments it takes deliberate effort to lure ease into daily life; an interesting conundrum.

As years click away, and the scope of opportunity narrows simply because the time left to accomplish things has narrowed, the impulse to return home grows stronger.  Orvieto, echoing the quiet melodies that kept Sunnyvale local in the 1950’s, feels like home. Half a world away, I relax back into a pace so familiar that it almost flows in my bloodstream.  I’m grateful to be here.  Come visit for more than a week or two, and you may find something similar.